LBI Real Estate Market Report June 2025

LBI Real Estate Market Update

June Market Minute

Get the latest LBI real estate market trends in under 2 minutes with our Market Minute series.

LBI Market Minute

May Recap

Summary

Following a sharp slowdown in April, buying activity rebounded strongly in May. Early signs of renewed momentum culminated in the week of 5/12, which saw 13 properties go under contractthe busiest week of the year so far. In total, 37 properties went under contract during the month, matching the trailing 12-month average and well above April’s total of 22. This resurgence can largely be attributed to improved confidence in the financial markets and the seasonal urgency among buyers aiming to secure a home before summer.

New listing activity fell short, with just 45 properties hitting the market. Combined with 24 expired, withdrawn, or canceled listings, total inventory declined by 16—from 135 to 119 active listings. The elevated number of expired listings reflects buyers’ continued price sensitivity and selectiveness, drawing a clear line on perceived market value.

The average sale-to-list price ratio came in at 96.4%, suggesting that while there is room for negotiation, buyers are not overpaying. Eight properties sold at or above asking, including one at 10% over list, while the steepest discount came in at 88% of asking.

While the average days to contract dropped from 66 to 55—indicating stronger demand for well-priced homes—the average days on market for active listings increased from 87 to 94. This divergence highlights a split market, where appropriately priced properties are moving quickly, while overpriced listings continue to sit.

June Outlook

Buyers

Since 2021, June has consistently been the slowest month for buyer activity. Many buyers step back, recognizing they won’t be able to use the home or generate rental income during the summer — all while prices still reflect peak-season premiums and few new listings come to market.

That pause in activity, however, creates opportunity. With the right guidance, buyers can take advantage of reduced competition to negotiate favorable deals — especially on aging inventory. The average days on market is 94 overall, climbing to 116 for homes priced above $2,500,000. And while new listings may be limited, many existing properties are now well-positioned for negotiation.

It’s worth acting soon — July through September have been the most active months for contracts over the past four years. As activity picks up, so does competition, potentially closing this brief window of added leverage.

Sellers

While June often sees quieter buying activity, this is largely driven by a lack of fresh inventory and many overpriced listings—meaning there are still active buyers ready to engage. With inventory down over 10% month-over-month and at its lowest level since February (119 listings), sellers—especially those in high-demand segments with limited competition—should seriously consider listing now.

It’s important to note that many sellers wait until July, aiming for a post-summer closing, only to face a surge of new listings. Since July through September are historically the busiest months for new inventory, listing now offers the advantage of less competition, the opportunity to secure a post-summer closing, and the ability to enjoy or rent your home during peak season—all while avoiding the hassle of summer showings.

That said, this decision should be made on a case-by-case basis, with professional guidance to assess buyer demand, local competition, and to craft the right pricing and marketing strategy for your specific property.

 

Featured Property

The Buccaneer Club

Final Units Remaining

Welcome to The Buccaneer Club- LBI’s newest luxury condo development featuring 20 units! A bayfront community “sitting a stone’s throw from the ocean.” Unit 8 is a north facing interior unit that boasts 2 bedrooms 2.5 baths and a second family room. The interior features an open floor plan with soaring ceilings that are efficiently designed to accommodate the many roles of the family beach house. Within the floors and walls, the structural system integrates engineered lumber and code surpassing stainless steel fasteners. Woodmode cabinetry and engineered hardwood flooring… along with quartz countertops are among the high quality products chosen for interior finishes. A 3 stop elevator, internally accessed rooftop deck, and ground level bonus room makes the home live large. This development is ideally located just two blocks to the beach and right outside of Beach Haven and all it has to offer. Sunrises and sunsets will abound from your home and the community space featuring a large heated, saltwater pool. Don’t miss this opportunity! Come see these properties ASAP!

Newest Listings

Browse by Community

The Guarino Real Estate Team

We’re a family real estate team that strongly believes there is no place like LBI. We are grateful for the opportunity to connect with those who share this affinity and educate newcomers about this beautiful New Jersey island.

Previous Market Reports

Questions? Call or text us today at 609-467-4061!