LBI Weekly Real Estate Report | March 31st, 2026
Real Estate Market Reports

LBI Weekly Real Estate Report | March 31st, 2026

LBI Real Estate - Beach Haven Park

March 31, 2026

Long Beach Island • Real Estate Market Snapshot

This Week on LBI

What's Going On On The Island

The island business scene is really starting to come back to life.

With it being Easter weekend, there’s more going on than usual for this time of year. A number of local spots are open, and there are a few Easter egg hunts happening across the island — including one at the popular new Tide Table restaurant, Hollow Pines.

We’ve already seen some of the early-season favorites reopen, including Okie’s, Country Kettle Chowda, and others, and that momentum is continuing this week. Spots like Birdy’s Café, Wittingham Market, Fratelli’s, and Shore Good Donuts are all reopening this week — a clear sign that the season is right around the corner.

There’s also some exciting new additions across the island. Yoga Bohemia is opening a new location on the north end in Harvey Cedars, filling a much-needed fitness gap on the north end of the island.

In Ship Bottom, a new golf simulator is on the way, set to take over the old Dollar General location. As a golfer, I’m personally excited to finally have a spot to get swings in on the island, and I’m very intrigued to see how it does — especially in the shoulder seasons when there’s less to do.

On the flip side, not all the news is positive. Greenheads will not be reopening this year after the fire that destroyed their building this past fall — a tough loss for the island, especially as it was one of the only spots offering a healthier, quick dining option.

With the event calendar still relatively quiet this time of year, it’s actually a great opportunity to check out some of the island’s newer ventures. LBI Distillery, which just opened — I’ve heard good things and it’s definitely on my list to check out in the coming weeks.

Beau

What's Going On In Real Estate

Activity this past weekend cooled off a bit, as open house traffic and overall buyer activity were down compared to the previous two weekends.

It’s tough to say exactly what caused the shift. It could be as simple as the cooler temperatures, but there may also be something larger at play. The stock market has remained volatile, oil prices have risen sharply, and there are growing concerns around inflation, along with mortgage rates ticking back up. While LBI tends to be more insulated from macroeconomic factors than most markets, it’s not completely immune — and it’s something to keep an eye on as the spring market unfolds.

One interesting signal right now is that there are a couple of higher-end properties priced very competitively that are still sitting on the market — homes we would have expected to move already.

Inventory has also stalled out, sitting in the mid-120s for the past couple of weeks. There’s a chance we push into the 130s, but it would be surprising to see it move much higher than that.

Looking at this month’s closings, out of 22 homes sold, only one went for over asking price. The average close-to-list ratio came in at 96.09%, which continues to show that many sellers are still coming to market priced too aggressively.

Of those 22 closings, 11 were cash and 11 were financed. Year-to-date, we’re at 36 cash deals versus 33 financed. We’ve steadily seen cash become a larger share of the market over time — last year was roughly 50/50, and this year is trending slightly higher on the cash side.

Looking ahead, last April and May we added 86 new listings, so expect to see a continued wave of inventory hit the market over the next 4–6 weeks. That should be followed by the typical pullback as we head into Memorial Day and the start of the summer season.

Drew

Want this delivered to your inbox every week?

Get our weekly LBI market updates, local happenings, and off-market opportunities sent directly to you.

Subscribe to the Weekly Newsletter
The Guarino Team 609-467-4061
Beau and Drew
Market Data — Guarino Team
Market Data
LBI Real Estate Activity
March 24 – March 30
13
New Listings
8
Under Contract
2
Expired
Net Listings Gained
+3
Scroll to explore the full market dashboard ↓

Search Properties

Explore curated listings sorted from highest to lowest price.


Highest to Lowest


Lowest to Highest


By Neighborhood


5004 Ocean Blvd – Brant Beach, LBI
9 William St, Harvey Cedars, NJ

Harvey Cedars · Long Beach Island

Bay-View Coastal Home in Harvey Cedars

9 William Street, Harvey Cedars

$2,774,900
5 Bedrooms
4.5 Full Baths
2,144 Square Feet
2011 Year Built

Offered at $2,774,900, this well-maintained bayblock home delivers elevated coastal living just one house off the bay in the heart of Harvey Cedars. Designed with a reverse-living layout, the property captures wide bay views from every level while offering a short walk to the ocean with deeded access. With thoughtful construction, multiple outdoor spaces, and a layout built for both entertaining and everyday comfort, this home blends classic LBI charm with modern functionality.

Property Highlights

Bay Views from Every Level
Positioned one off the bay, the home offers sweeping water views and stunning sunset exposure from multiple decks and a rooftop space.
Reverse-Living Design
Open-concept top floor with a bright great room, vaulted ceilings, and a seamless flow between kitchen, dining, and living areas.
Quality Construction & Elevator
Built in 2011 with an elevator to all floors, hardwood flooring, and a well-appointed kitchen with stainless appliances and granite countertops.
Multiple Outdoor Living Spaces
Several decks plus a rooftop deck provide ideal spaces for entertaining, relaxing, and taking in panoramic bay sunsets.
Why We Like It

Harvey Cedars remains one of the most desirable locations on the north end, with bayblock homes offering strong views and consistent demand. The reverse-living layout and rooftop deck maximize light, exposure, and overall appeal.

A major advantage here is the ability to offer five bedrooms at this price point — a meaningful upgrade from four in both hosting and rental potential. Paired with strong bay views and walkability to both the beach and bay, this is the type of property that continues to perform and hold value over time.


Quick Snapshot

Price$2,774,900
Bedrooms / Bathrooms5 beds · 4 full baths · 1 half bath
Square Footage2,144 sq ft
Year Built2011
LocationHarvey Cedars · Long Beach Island
ViewsBay Views
Outdoor SpaceMultiple decks + rooftop deck
Parking2-car garage + driveway
View Full Listing

Courtesy of Annemarie Aresco · BHHS Zack Shore Realtors

LBI Locals
LBI Locals Featured Island Guide

The Perfect LBI Bachelorette Weekend Itinerary

The Guarino Team

The Island's Fastest-Growing Real Estate Team

The Guarino Real Estate Team

We're not just here to open doors — we're here to make sure you walk through the right one.

We don't just know the Long Beach Island market. We live it, invest in it, and study it every single day.

From accurate pricing guidance and rental ROI projections to strategic offer structures that win in competitive situations, we help buyers approach the market with clarity and confidence.

With deep local roots, modern valuation technology, and a relentless work ethic, we're redefining what a real estate advisor should be.

Ready to Begin Your LBI Journey?

It's never too early to reach out. The more time we have to understand what you're looking for, the better positioned you'll be when the right property comes along.

Featured Market Insight

NJ 4-Foot Flood Rule — What It Means for LBI

NJ 4 Foot Flood Rule Long Beach Island
The Guarino Team
About the author

The Guarino Team

The Guarino Team is a family-run, top-ranked real estate team on Long Beach Island, led by Vincent Guarino and his sons, Drew and Beau. Combining deep local roots with a modern, data-driven approach, the team helps buyers, sellers, and investors navigate the LBI market with confidence. Backed by their experience at Freeman & Company Real Estate—the highest transactional brokerage on LBI—and with offices in Harvey Cedars and Beach Haven, they bring the expertise and perspective needed to navigate complex situations and optimize outcomes for their clients.