February 10, 2026
Long Beach Island • Real Estate Market Snapshot
This Week on LBI
What’s Going On On The Island
LBI Restaurant Week wrapped up last weekend as we head into Valentine’s Day, marking one of the busier stretches of the winter season for local dining. While many spots operate on limited off-season schedules, several of the island’s top upscale options remain open. Raimondo’s, Black Eyed Susan’s, Azzurri, and The Gables are all currently serving, giving both locals and weekend visitors strong dining options without the summer crowds.
In restaurant news, Joe Pop’s was sold a little while back and there had been some uncertainty surrounding the future of the space. New ownership has since confirmed that Joe Pop’s will continue operating much as it has in the past, welcome news for longtime regulars heading toward the spring season.
Another positive year-round development: Flour Child Pizza, widely considered to have some of the best pizza on the island, has officially committed to staying open year-round, continuing the trend of more businesses extending their seasons and keeping the island active through the winter.
Due to recent winter weather, the Annual LBI Polar Plunge has been rescheduled to March 1. The event remains one of the island’s largest off-season community fundraisers each year.
Another off-season note: unlike previous winters, Hudson House is now open on weekends. While it remains a drinks-focused dive bar with no food service, it has quickly become one of the few consistent late-winter nightlife spots open across the island.
What’s Going On In Real Estate
The recent stretch of winter weather has put a noticeable damper on market activity across Long Beach Island. Over the past week, just one property went under contract, reflecting how travel conditions and storms have kept many buyers off the island and temporarily slowed momentum.
After a relatively quiet couple of weeks from a listing standpoint, we are beginning to see new inventory emerge. There are now 92 active listings on the market island-wide, and there is a strong likelihood inventory returns to triple digits by month-end. Historically, February and March tend to be two of the stronger months for new listings as sellers prepare for the spring market.
As we’ve reiterated in recent reports, there is a very clear divide forming between homes that are priced correctly and those that are overpriced. Well-positioned properties are generating immediate interest and moving quickly, while homes that stretch pricing are increasingly being passed over.
To better illustrate this trend, we recently put together a visual breaking down days on market by price range.
In the $1–2M segment, homes that have closed within the past 100 days averaged just 10 days on market. Meanwhile, properties currently sitting for sale in that same price range are averaging closer to 80 days on market. The gap highlights how sensitive today’s buyers are to pricing and how quickly the market responds when a property is positioned correctly.
No matter your price range, there will be opportunities hitting the market in the coming months as new inventory builds heading toward spring. It will be important to identify and act on the right opportunities quickly — well-priced homes are still moving in a matter of days, not weeks.
If you’d like assistance navigating the current market or simply want a clearer read on where things stand, we’re always happy to help provide perspective as conditions continue to evolve.
609-467-4061
Market Data 📈
Activity Reporting Window:
February 4 - February 10, 2026
10 New Listings
1 Under Contract
4 Expireds
+5 net listings gained
New Listings
Fresh on the market — the island’s newest listings.
Search Properties
Explore curated listings sorted from highest to lowest price.
Highest to Lowest
Lowest to Highest
By Neighborhood
Featured Listing
Classic Coastal Home in Ship Bottom
📍 108 22nd Street W, Ship Bottom, NJ 08008
Offered at $1,649,999, this well-maintained coastal home combines classic beach charm with modern updates and flexible living space. Just a short stroll to the ocean and close to everything Ship Bottom has to offer, the property includes multiple outdoor decks, an open floor plan, and plenty of room for beach living, gatherings, or rental use.
Property Highlights
- 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms with bright, spacious layouts and great natural light.
- Built in 2000, with meaningful updates and modern coastal finishes.
- Open-concept kitchen and living area that works well for entertaining and everyday use.
- Multiple outdoor decks plus a fenced backyard for dining, relaxing, and hosting.
- Attached 1-car garage with additional driveway parking.
Why We Like It
This property sits on a rare 80’ x 100’ lot—an exceptional find on the south end of the island—offering meaningful long-term upside. It allows you to update and enjoy the home now, while the oversized lot provides outstanding flexibility for a future new build when the time is right.
From a pricing standpoint, we feel this is positioned appropriately for Ship Bottom given the combination of location, condition, and the size of the underlying land.
Quick Snapshot
| Price | $1,649,999 |
| Bedrooms / Bathrooms | 4 beds, 3 baths |
| Square Footage | ~2,184 sq ft |
| Year Built | 2000 |
| Location | Ship Bottom, Long Beach Island |
Courtesy of Craig Stefanoni, BHHS Zack Shore REALTORS
Whittingham Coffee House: A Coffee Shop with a Great Community
The Guarino Team
The Island’s Fastest-Growing Real Estate Team
Anyone can unlock a door — we unlock opportunity.
We don’t just know the Long Beach Island market. We live it, invest in it, and study it every single day.
From accurate pricing guidance and rental ROI projections to strategic offer structures that win in competitive situations, we help buyers approach the market with clarity and confidence.
With deep local roots, modern valuation technology, and a relentless work ethic, we're redefining what a real estate advisor should be.